In
1861, a Dutch scholar named Rheinhart Dozy published a work that is entirely
dated in its style and approach, has been superseded in much of its analysis,
and yet remains gloriously, exuberantly rich in romantic detail and anecdote
and passion. A kind of Arabian Nights approach to history. The English reprint of
his great work, entitled Muslims in
Spain, is more than 750 pages long (fair warning!) but it was probably this
book that most powerfully set my imagination to work on the cast of characters
I encountered.
Much
more modern, much more accessible, are two books by Richard Fletcher, and these
would be my suggested starting points for any general reader. Moorish Spain is witty and fast without
being trivial, and The Quest for El Cid
is a wonderful book that tracks the life and legend of the Iberian hero while
also opening a window onto the enormous significance the image of El Cid still
has in Spanish intellectual and popular culture.
Researching
the debate about this started the line of thought about history and fantasy and
the use of 'real' people in fiction that comes up in one of my essays posted
elsewhere on this site [Webmaster's note: 'Home and Away']. It also gave me a new intellectual figure to admire, a
Spanish historian and cultural analyst named Americo Castro. His major book is
called (in English), The Spaniards: An
Introduction to Their History. It is Castro who represents the strand in
Spanish intellectual thought that sees modern Spain as a product of the three
cultures that interacted in the middle ages, whereas his intellectual opponents
saw - and see - Spain today as emerging from Visogothic society, regarding the
Arab centuries, with their Jewish influences as, fundamentally, a trivial
interlude leaving little behind today.)
More
scholarly than Fletcher, and more narrowly focused in its treatment of a period
in the history of Al-Andalus, is David Wasserstein's The Rise and Fall of the Party-Kings. (The party-kings is the
awkward name given to the petty statelets and their monarchs formed after the
fall of the Caliphate.) The second half of the book has sections entitled 'The
Christians', 'The Moslems' and 'The Jews' and examines their respective roles
and niches in 11th century society. This is good, highly useful history.
Roger
Collin's Early Medieval Spain seems
to be pretty much the standard scholarly introduction to the period up to the
year 1000 (I know that's a risky thing to say and I'm not up-to-date on work in the last several years!) The next volume
in the same highly respected series is by Angus MacKay, entitled Spain in the Middle Ages, and takes the
story from 1000-1500. I also used T.F. Glick's, Islamic and Christian Spain in the early Middle Ages, though he
isn't what I would call a fluid prose stylist.
On
medicine, I like Nancy G. Siraisi's Medieval
and Early Renaissance Medicine. A reproduction (page 28 of the University
of Chicago edition) of a medieval picture of a woman physician holding a urine
flask was obviously a catalyst for me!
There
is a magnificent book entitled Convivencia:
Jews, Muslims, and Christians in Medieval Spain, and the images and essays
(the book was written to accompany an exhibit at the Jewish Museum in New York
in 1992) gave me a great deal of material. So did an even more sumptuous
exhibition catalogue from a show at the Metropolitan Museum in New York: Al-Andalus, the Art of Moslem Spain. Gorgeous
book.
I
found the wonderful poetry of Moslem and Jewish Spain in many different places
and different translations. A. J. Arberry has one such book, entitled Moorish Poetry. It translates an
anthology made in the 13th century. The
Poem of the Cid, the epic version of the hero's tale is available widely
and in many versions.
next...
|